For a country like India, with a huge population of deal seekers, cashback platform CashKaro grew fast to become the country’s largest cash reward site. But in the past couple of years, ecommerce businesses have faced tough times — companies like Askme Bazaar, Tiny Owl, among others, have ceased to exist. Others like Snapdeal will soon be gobbled by Flipkart.
“Any online business is very dependent on ecommerce. Two years ago, Askme and Paytm were big customers for us — some of them are not around anymore,” says Swati Bhargava, cofounder of CashKaro.
The uncertainty of the ecommerce industry can also become a spoiler for CashKaro, which has been funded for $4.55 million by Kalaari Capital and billionaire Ratan Tata. Bhargava and her cofounder husband Rohan started thinking a year ago about the problem — how find a foothold in the offline space.
The uncertainty of the ecommerce industry can also become a spoiler for CashKaro… Swati Bhargava and her cofounder husband Rohan started thinking a year ago about the problem — how find a foothold in the offline space
Barely 2% to 3% of the nearly $600 billion total retail spending in India happens online. Off and on, internet companies including Snapdeal, Paytm, among others have tried to target the offline buyer, but have not been able to bridge the gap quite successfully.
So far, CashKaro has been targeting the same buyers Amazon, Flipkart, and others go after, by giving an additional discount on every purchase. This discount, in form of a cashback, is funded by the ecommerce company as a part of the affiliate marketing activity.
The affiliate marketing business, Bhargava reckons is worth $2 billion, a third of which is cashback. CashKaro, she says, does $100 million of gross merchandise value a year.
To grow, why can’t the same logic apply for offline retailers, thought the CashKaro cofounders. They met executives from Edo Interactive, the US-based company that links credit and debit cards, to avail cashbacks when a purchase is done online or at a retail store.
A cashback partner in banks
Comparison sites like Junglee (owned by Amazon) help in comparing offline and online prices, but that doesn’t close the entire loop of purchase. Add to that the fact that coupon codes are slowly becoming irrelevant. The problem with the coupon business is that at the point of sale (POS), banks had make to technology changes to incorporate coupon codes, which they didn’t want to do.
“The question was how to make money offline,” says Bhargava. “It was difficult to convince the banks.” For that, CashKaro had to become more than just a cashback company, and turn into a technology company that could bring together the bank, merchant, buyer and cashbacks on the same platform.
Meanwhile, to retain customers, banks were giving out expensive cashbacks. Here was CashKaro’s chance to break through. Bhargava offered Yes Bank an unique proposition (the first bank partnership): CashKaro would tie-up with the merchant, get the deals; YesBank would open up their customer base, identify the customers that the merchant wants to target; and together they would make cashback offers, which would be funded from the merchant’s wallet.
“The bank doesn’t have to pay for the cashback, and there is revenue in it for them. We make target segments of the database, and each retailer can target one segment and give them an offer” — Swati Bhargava, cofounder of CashKaro
For example, Starbucks wants to target customers who have not visited the coffee chain for more than a month. CashKaro would ask Yes Bank to find those users, depending on their card swiping history, and then push the offer, to be redeemed at the cafe. The deal will be preloaded on the account and can be redeemed automatically when the credit or debit card is swiped. The money will get transferred directly to the bank account. (Earlier it would go to the user’s CashKaro account.)
“The bank doesn’t have to pay for the cashback, and there is revenue in it for them. We make target segments of the database, and each retailer can target one segment and give them an offer,” says Bhargava.
The Google of ecommerce
Market experts are not convinced with cashback companies being able to target the offline market. “There need to be large loyalties, which can’t be attained with Rs 2 to Rs 5 cashbacks. So, if you get a cashback from McDonald’s, the buyer should be able to use that at other retailers. A lot of people have tried this, but they have not been able to scale,” says Mohammed Imthiaz, founder and CEO of hyperlocal rewards and offers company Hoppr, which was acquired by Hike Messenger in August 2015.
A competitor who doesn’t want to be named says it’s early to declare success. “It’s a good move to tap the offline market… but only one tie-up is not enough, CashKaro will need scale, many tie-ups with banks and merchants,” says the cofounder of another cashback site.
Bhargava says that it’s on its way to seal deals with 100 brands, such as Madura brands, Reliance, Arvind, Pantaloons, Arrow, Pizza Hut, restaurant chains.
“It’s a good move to tap the offline market… but only one tie-up is not enough, CashKaro will need scale, many tie-ups with banks and merchants” — Cofounder of another cashback site
Eventually, says Bhargava, her husband has the ambition to “be the Google of Indian ecommerce” — where people should be able to get the cashback quickly, search for products quickly, and all of that through a smart, predictive search engine.
CashKaro will also use artificial intelligence and big data make these processes easier. “Predicting customer behaviour intelligence will be useful… We will also see a lot of innovation in online businesses, which is only possible by a product company, and not by just being cashback site,” says Bhargava.
In the near future, if you type Apple iPhone, it will show you places, price and available cashback on an iPhone, both online and offline. The same card will be swiped both online and offline, and everything will be linked to a single payment mechanism, says Bhargava. She is also in talks with other banks — some deals are in the final stage, which Bhargava doesn’t want to disclose.
Subscribe to FactorDaily
Our daily brief keeps thousands of readers ahead of the curve. More signals, less noise.
Disclosure: FactorDaily is owned by SourceCode Media, which counts Accel Partners, Blume Ventures and Vijay Shekhar Sharma among its investors. Accel Partners is an early investor in Flipkart. Vijay Shekhar Sharma is the founder of Paytm. None of FactorDaily’s investors have any influence on its reporting about India’s technology and startup ecosystem.